Showing posts with label Biography. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Biography. Show all posts

Monday, February 14, 2011

Review: QUEEN VICTORIA by Giles Lytton Strachey


As a student of history, Queen Victoria has always fascinated me, because with her long reign, the leader of Britain at its largest point, her nine children and multitudes of grand and great-grand children, it is difficult to find a corner of the world which she didn’t influence. 

Victoria was conceived specifically for political purposes.  Her father, the Duke of Kent, married a young widow for the express purpose of producing an heir before his brothers could do so.  Growing up, she knew that she was of aristocratic birth, but her mother, in an attempt to keep her from being spoiled, hid from her how close she was to the throne.  By the time the truth was revealed to her in her early teens, Victoria was well on her way to becoming an intelligent, pious and poised young woman.  In 1837, at the age of eighteen, Victoria inherited the throne, which she held until her death in 1901.  During her reign, the British Empire was in its Golden Age.  British innovation and technology ushered the world into the modern era.   

One of the most interesting things that I learned in this book was Albert’s role, not just as Victoria’s husband, but also as a co-ruler.  The pair perfectly complimented each other.  Where Victoria was social, a natural diplomat, Albert was detail oriented and serious.  For twenty years, Albert, an intelligent and brilliant strategist, dedicated himself morning to night in the work of running a kingdom.  He literally worked himself to an early death (he died at age 42), but the British people of the time never truly accepted him.  As a German prince, he was a foreigner.  His anti-social ways did not ingratiate him to the aristocracy.  But for as much as the people didn’t care for him, Albert made his mark on the empire by putting its needs and its people before himself.

I view the “love story” of Victoria and Albert as a tragic one.  Although it basically had been an arranged marriage (they had a choice, but it was limited), Victoria loved him with her whole heart—so much so that after his death, she mourned him for the rest of her long life.  They had nine children together and had a perfect partnership.  Even so, while Albert cared for her as a dear friend and respected her for her mind, he never truly loved her.  In fact, Albert never really achieved any sort of personal happiness.  His death had as much to do with his melancholy attitude as it did with illness. 

As biographies go, I really enjoyed this one.  It made me think.  My biggest problem with the book is that I was reading it in electronic format and as it is with many public domain books, there were a lot of formatting errors.  While I was able to figure out what the author was trying to say, it was visually annoying. 

Overall, I give Queen Victoria…

Plot – 3 ½ bookmarks (while interesting, it was a bit slow in spots)
Love Story – 4 bookmarks (although tragic)
Historical Relevance – 5 bookmarks (to understand Victoria & the Victorian Age is to understand the world we live in today)
Dream Cast (Otherwise known as who I pictured while reading) – I saw the movie Young Victoria a while back, starring Emily Blunt as Victoria and Rupert Friend as Albert.  These are who I had in mind for the first half of the book.  After Albert’s death I pictured the actually Queen Victoria with her heavy black mourning clothes.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

Review: MY BIOLOGICAL FAMILY by Helen Johansen

I debated with myself about reviewing this book for a lot of reasons.  First, it is not a published book.  It was written by my great-aunt Helen and distributed throughout my family.  Second, I have some issues with the subject of the book and how it was told.  What made me decide to write a comment on this was actually my post last week regarding the burying of family secrets and how those stories could have historical importance.  A lot of people in my family are upset by this book.  They see it as an invasion of privacy and claim there are a lot of misrepresentation of facts.  Maybe there are.  I wouldn’t know.  My grandmother and many other people written about, are deceased. 

This story revolves around my grandmother’s family living in Nebraska during the Depression.  When my great-grandmother died of malnutrition, she left behind five daughters and two sons ranging in age from two months to twelve years old.  My great-grandfather was an alcoholic and the family lived in poverty.  A year later, my great-grandfather was arrested and sent to prison for raping his two eldest daughters and impregnating one of them.  After his arrest, the children went into an orphanage.  The only sibling to go on to be adopted was the baby, Helen. 

Without going into the private details of people still living, I’ll just say that the six elder kids lead rough lives.  A few went on to find happiness as adults.  The others were emotionally scarred and went on to raise the next generation in disturbing and unhealthy atmospheres.  Helen was the fortunate one.  She is too young to remember her biological parents or the orphanage.  She grew up loved and cared for and healthy.  She talks in the books beginning about how fortunate she was and how lucky she was not to have a life like her siblings. 

My question is, was this even Helen’s story to tell?  Ninety percent of the story revolves around other people, with Helen reporting gossip that she had heard.  Sure, the ‘main characters’ were her biological family, but she never lived the horrors that they did.  Even I found facts that were incorrect, and I don’t pretend to understand all that went on in that family.  As far as I’m aware, none of the family was even interviewed.  The first they knew of their histories being documented and made public was when the bound copy showed up in the mail. 

Molestation, incest, physical abuse, malnutrition and poverty are hell on children.  The way they deal with it can range from burying it to the point of amnesia all the way to broadcasting their story via talk show circuit.  Is it their story to tell or does anyone with a stake in the DNA have the right to share it?  Should these types of stories be told without the consent of the victims?  How much time should have to pass before it is time to document family histories?  I honestly don’t know the answers to these questions.  If the emotions are too raw, these histories can be hurtful to those involved.  If too much time passes, the facts run the risk of being distorted.  Both of these things happened with Aunt Helen’s book.  I’m curious about what you all think about these issues.  What are the responsibilities of the family historian? 

Monday, September 27, 2010

Review: BOLD SPIRIT by Linda Hunt


I am a firm believer that buried in every family is a story.  Some stories are heroic, some are tragic, some tell of great loves, others of great losses.  Unfortunately, many of these stories are lost to time due to lack of preservation.  Sometimes people close to the situations are embarrassed by them.  Sometimes they assume no one else would be interested.  Bold Spirit tells of a story that was almost lost forever when the family of Helga Estby purposely burnt Helga’s memoires.  Only a few newspaper articles saved from the ashes by Helga’s daughter-in-law and hidden away are left to remember Helga’s historic feat.

Bold Spirit is the true story of Helga Estby, a Norwegian immigrant, who walked from Spokane, Washington to New York City in the late 1800’s.  When Helga was thirty-six years old, her family was suffering under a recession and fighting the foreclosure on their farm.  This desperation to save her home and to keep her husband and nine kids from starving, led Helga to accept a wager from a wealthy person in the NY fashion industry.  This sponsor wanted to promote shorter skirts, which would show a woman’s ankles (not really, the women wore high boots) and would allow more freedom of movement.  The sponsor promised Helga $10,000 if she would walk from Spokane to New York wearing the new shorter skirt.  This would promote the new fashion as well as support the growing women’s right movement.  Helga was only allowed to leave her home with $5 and was expected to earn her way across the country by selling pictures of herself.  She had seven months to complete the trip. 

So, on a cold Spring morning, Helga and her daughter, Clara, set forth on a walk which would take them across the country.  They used the local newspaper in each town that they stopped in to promote their walk and to drum up picture sales.  (It is this public record of small town newspaper articles which made writing this book possible.)  Along the way, Helga and Clara learned about the American Spirit and hospitality.  They lost their prejudices of the Native Americans.  They learned the physical strength that women possessed. 

I don’t want to give anything away.  Let’s just say, her kids at home were not happy about their mother traipsing all over the country while they were suffering at home.  These children burnt Helga’s memoires and forbid mention of Helga’s great journey.  Besides providing a snapshot of American history, Helga’s story taught me the importance of preserving our family histories. 

Overall, I give Bold Spirit…

Plot – 3 ½ bookmarks
Character Development – 2 bookmarks (This is low mostly because very little first-hand information on Helga exists.  The author had to piece her together through our sources.)
History – 4 bookmarks
Dream Cast (otherwise known as who I pictured while reading) – Tilda Swinton (Helga)